Key Takeaways:
Modern Science Replaced Medieval Church Authority
COVID was Eerily Similar to the Black Death
Peer Review Reveals Corruption in the Sciences
Modern Science Replaced Medieval Church Authority
During the Middle Ages, the Roman Catholic Church was the intellectual authority that separated fact from fiction for Europeans. Those who dared to contradict Church doctrine suffered the harshest penalties imaginable. Heretics risked being burned at the stake, or having their bodies agonizingly pulled apart in the dungeons of the Inquisition.
But toward the end of the Middle Ages, the Church forfeited its intellectual monopoly. After the arrival of the Black Death in the mid-1300s, Europeans began harboring serious doubts about the cornerstone of the Church’s monopoly; its direct connection to God.
As the Church’s monopoly over the flow of ideas crumbled, European society descended into the political chaos of the Protestant Reformation. Order was restored with the Enlightenment, when a new scientific authority arose to fill the vacuum left by the momentous collapse of Church authority.
Today, science defines reality for the general public as the Church once did. The modern priests who separate reality from heresy on behalf of the public now wear white lab coats instead of clerical frocks. Heretics are no longer burned at the stake, but those who question science instead endure professional disqualification and social marginalization.
The Mexican artist Diego Rivera vividly illustrated the point when he arrived in Detroit to create a series of murals during the Great Depression. There, he revived old Church iconography by recreating the Madonna-with-child nativity motif that once dominated Medieval artwork.
But in Rivera’s updated version, the holy child receives a vaccination shot from a scientist dressed in a white lab coat. Three “wise men” perform experiments in the background. With this scene, Rivera aimed to celebrate one of the many blessings science has bestowed upon humankind.
But his reuse of an old faith-based motif also showcases an important historical parallel. The general public doesn’t conduct experiments. Nor do most of us read peer-reviewed studies. Instead, we take the declarations of the scientific authorities on faith, just as the Medieval public once uncritically accepted the doctrines of the Roman Catholic Church.
COVID was Eerily Similar to the Black Death
Toward the end of the Middle Ages, the Black Death played a major role in undermining the credibility of the Roman Catholic Church. Lacking a germ theory of disease, Church officials were conspicuously powerless to stop the dying. Priests died in even greater numbers than the laity, because their performance of Last Rites brought them into disproportionate contact with a pathogen they couldn’t understand.
Grave doubts about the Church’s supposed connection to God festered in the aftermath. Throughout the Medieval period, Church officials claimed a monopoly on direct contact with God. But this authoritative role as divine intermediary was no longer believable after the plague carried off half the population of Europe.
The recent COVID pandemic mirrored the Black Death in that the pandemic response of our modern authorities shook the faith of millions of people. Corporations and political figures, for example, shamelessly borrowed the good name of medical science to exaggerate claims about the efficacy of mRNA therapies lucratively marketed as “vaccines.”
Furthermore—during the darkest days of COVID—massive platforms like YouTube frequently removed, demonetized, or suppressed content implicating a lab leak in the outbreak of the pandemic. Facebook enforced an explicit policy against content supporting the lab leak hypothesis, which is now widely accepted as fact.
Additionally, the Great Barrington Declaration of 2020 was a dissenting opinion from inside the sciences. It vociferously opposed the lockdowns that were centerpieces of pandemic responses the world over. Almost a million people signed it, including tens of thousands of medical practitioners and public health scientists.
The Great Barrington Declaration demonstrates that it isn’t the principles of science that have become corrupt, but rather its institutions which have become flawed. For better or for worse, public skepticism toward scientific authority is now undeniably on the rise.
This phenomenon mirrors the skepticism of the Roman Catholic Church aroused by the Black Death. Before these pandemics, public faith in institutions like the Medieval Church or the modern sciences was near universal. But afterward, whole societies were left hopelessly divided along political lines—like Protestant versus Catholic, or Democrat versus Republican.
The COVID pandemic didn’t come with the catastrophic loss of life that made the Black Death one of history’s most terrifying episodes. But it did undermine the credibility of the authorities in a manner eerily reminiscent of the horrific plague that ravaged Europe during the 1300s.
Peer Review Reveals Corruption in the Sciences
There is perhaps no more salient example of corruption in the halls of science than “peer review.” It’s considered the gold standard in scientific research, but such was not always the case.
Peer review is a criteria by which new scientific findings are accepted only after they’ve been approved by additional scientists beyond the original publisher. Though this process serves as a valuable failsafe, it also reinforces orthodoxy.
From the Enlightenment through the 1960s, peer review was not the fixture in the sciences that it is today. Google’s ENGRAM viewer—which visualizes the frequency of words or phrases over time by analyzing the text of millions of digitized books—reveals an exponential explosion in the usage of that phrase during the 60s.
Scientific findings are published and peer-reviewed in scientific or academic journals. The publishing model for these journals was pioneered by a firm called Pergammon Press during the 1960s. During that decade, the concept of peer review was heavily promoted by Robert Maxwell, the owner of Pergammon Press.
Maxwell’s efforts to normalize peer review is unmistakably apparent with Google Ngram. Pushing that concept created a guaranteed subscription at every university in the world for Maxwell’s academic journals, making him a vast fortune.
In 1960, Pergammon published 59 academic journals. By 1992, that number had ballooned to 418 different publications. In this way, the profit motive—rather than the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake—shaped a core structure of modern science through Maxwell’s aggressive promotion of peer review.
But the most interesting thing about Robert Maxwell, of course, is that his daughter is Ghislaine Maxwell. Ghislaine is the convicted accomplice to sex trafficker and financier Jeffrey Epstein. Along with Epstein’s own well-documented obsession with science, this connection provides a penetrating insight into a corrupt overlap between the sciences and high finance.
The Roman Catholic Church gradually transformed into a corrupt authority during the Middle Ages, before its reputation finally collapsed in the wake of the Black Death. Our institutions of modern science are undergoing a similar metamorphosis; the COVID era exposed a similar lapse into inflexible orthodoxy.
As controversy over Jeffrey Epstein swirls in the aftermath of COVID, we find ourselves in a historical moment disturbingly reminiscent of the late Middle Ages. Then as now, it’s slowly dawning on a dismayed public that trusted authorities have quietly compromised with the truth in order to preserve their own power and influence.
Conclusion
Like Christianity, science began as a rebellion against entrenched authorities. But the institutions that sprang up around these ideologies followed a predictable pattern as they succumbed to the realities of human nature. In both cases, pandemics exposed those compromises to a horrified public. The crises of faith that follow such events are hallmarks of the transition periods between systems of economic authority. The Black Death set in motion a chain of events that led to a widespread rejection of Christianity, and to its ultimate replacement with science. As the modern capitalist economic system circles the drain, COVID has launched another crisis of faith during another great turning of the age.
Since you made it this far, versatile reader, kindly consider hitting the ❤️ button above or below; it really helps!
Further Materials
Coming from both the left and right, and around the world, we have devoted our careers to protecting people. Current lockdown policies are producing devastating effects on short and long-term public health. The results (to name a few) include lower childhood vaccination rates, worsening cardiovascular disease outcomes, fewer cancer screenings and deteriorating mental health – leading to greater excess mortality in years to come, with the working class and younger members of society carrying the heaviest burden. Keeping students out of school is a grave injustice. Keeping these measures in place until a vaccine is available will cause irreparable damage, with the underprivileged disproportionately harmed. Fortunately, our understanding of the virus is growing. We know that vulnerability to death from COVID-19 is more than a thousand-fold higher in the old and infirm than the young. Indeed, for children, COVID-19 is less dangerous than many other harms, including influenza. As immunity builds in the population, the risk of infection to all – including the vulnerable – falls. We know that all populations will eventually reach herd immunity – i.e. the point at which the rate of new infections is stable – and that this can be assisted by (but is not dependent upon) a vaccine. Our goal should therefore be to minimize mortality and social harm until we reach herd immunity.
The Great Barrington Declaration, October 4, 2020








